Un-making The Opposition’s Case . . . .

un make  the argument

We could call this rhetorical technique — “Un-making The Opposition’s Case.”

In one sense, because Dominic Smart knows where he is going, he is setting up the listeners for a counter-argument which some may be or may not be making.

He is going to properly portray the people of the Exodus as those who wanted to go back, turn the clock back in spite of having the clear and awesome promises of God.  The promise given to Israel is “in black and white”  (hold on to that phrase).

Smart is making the argument for moving forward in the work of the church he pastors, arguing for moving forward.  Some might make the argument that we have not been given a promise as had Israel.  There is no “call & promise” to move ahead in the work of God, here in Gilcomston, Scotland.



(clip  – with all three  transcibed sections below) or (@24:55 mark – Dominic Smart – Be like Caleb)


You know what the people said


You remember what the people said in – in Joshua -in Numbers Chapter fourteen? — if only we had died in Egypt or in this desert.


Would it been better for us to go back to Egypt!  – verse four — We should choose a leader and go back to Egypt.

They wanted to turn the clock back.


It seemed to them – preferable – to go back to Egypt than to move forward to where God had promised.


Now at this point, some of you are sitting there and saying – Oh that’s all right Dominic — but God had promised that the people were going into the land


and He promised them a land flowing with milk and honey and that was a promise given to Abraham, Isaac, Jacob and all the rest.


and the promise had being given through Moses and Joshua and Caleb


So that was the promise of God that they were working on  — we’ve actually got it in black and white in our Bibles – here Dominic!


whereas the promise that governs …(Gilcomston)..  that’s a different kind of fish – maybe that’s you Dominic – just being a space head.



Then Smart makes the case that they have been given promises, just like Israel.



(immediately follows)


But you see the promise that the church will grow – is in black and white in your Bible


That God is a God Who sows seed because He expects and will reap the harvest  is in black and white in your Bible


That Jesus Christ’s government will never stop increasing – is in your Bible – chapter nine verse seven


See the God who grows his church  – is known to us as the God who grows his church – because it says it in your Bible


The question is — Do we believe it?


Do we believe that when we go out with the gospel and invite people in – to hear the gospel – that the Gospel really is God’s power for salvation.


Then, several minutes later, Smart states a possible reason for dismissing or marginalizing his point.*  Smart states a different counter-argument, and one more time he drives home his point with the same phraseology  (“in the Bible”).




“Oh [some might say], Maybe it is the day of small things.”


Show me  – THAT – in the Bible — cause that isn’t there!


But “I will build my church and the gates of Hell will not prevail against it” – that is there!



*Some might call this a “straw-man” argument – if it is not actually or generally held or stated by “some.”

That phrase “the day of small things” – Zech 4:10 – is found in the Bible, but as Smart states, such a comment would have to be taken out of its context to apply it to the growth of God’s church.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.